Wednesday, February 20, 2013 34 comments ++[ CLICK TO COMMENT ]++

The Disastrous Outsourcing of the 787

source: Boeing

The Boeing 787 Dreamliner is a technological marvel. It’s built largely of carbon-fibre composites rather than aluminum, which makes it significantly lighter than other planes. Its braking, pressurization, and air-conditioning systems are run not by hydraulics but by electricity from lithium-ion batteries. It uses twenty per cent less fuel than its peers, and so is cheaper to run, yet it also manages to have higher ceilings and larger windows. It is, in other words, one of the coolest planes in the air. Or, rather, on the ground: regulators around the world have grounded all fifty Dreamliners... The Dreamliner was supposed to become famous for its revolutionary design. Instead, it’s become an object lesson in how not to build an airplane.
— James Surowiecki, "Requiem for a Dreamliner?"

Don't have much time to comment on this but it appears that the outsourcing trend is probably near its end. Like all management concepts, outsourcing tactics over the last decade generated a lot of wealth and made companies more efficient, but it has resulted in some disastrous outcomes. The textbook example presently is Boeing and its 787 airplane; I am sure there will be even worse examples to come.

The following diagram illustrates the various suppliers of the 787:

It's still not clear if outsourcing may be the entire cause of the 787's problems but one can't deny that it played a major role.

The Economist once touched on the reasons for outsourcing:
But the business logic behind outsourcing remains compelling, so long as it is done right. Many tasks are peripheral to a firm's core business and can be done better and more cheaply by specialists. Cleaning is an obvious example; many back-office jobs also fit the bill. Outsourcing firms offer labour arbitrage, using cheap Indians to enter data rather than expensive Swedes. They can offer economies of scale, too.
Having said that, as is often the case for those trying to implement something well past its shelf life—Six Sigma approach in the early 2000s comes to mind—the incremental benefit of outsourcing appears to be declining significantly. It's difficult to say what went wrong with Boeing but James Surowiecki appears to suggest that Boeing outsourced itself out of its core business:
Boeing didn’t outsource just the manufacturing of parts; it turned over the design, the engineering, and the manufacture of entire sections of the plane to some fifty “strategic partners.” Boeing itself ended up building less than forty per cent of the plane.

This strategy was trumpeted as a reinvention of manufacturing. But while the finance guys loved it—since it meant that Boeing had to put up less money—it was a huge headache for the engineers. In a fascinating study of the process, two U.C.L.A. researchers, Christopher Tang and Joshua Zimmerman, show how challenging it was for Boeing to work with fifty different partners. The more complex a supply chain, the more chances there are for something to go wrong, and Boeing had far less control than it would have if more of the operation had been in-house. Delays became endemic, and, instead of costing less, the project went billions over budget. In 2011, Jim Albaugh, who took over the program in 2009, said, “We spent a lot more money in trying to recover than we ever would have spent if we’d tried to keep the key technologies closer to home.” And the missed deadlines created other issues. Determined to get the Dreamliners to customers quickly, Boeing built many of them while still waiting for the F.A.A. to certify the plane to fly; then it had to go back and retrofit the planes in line with the F.A.A.’s requirements. “If the saying is check twice and build once, this was more like build twice and check once,” Aboulafia said to me.
The situation at Boeing isn't as bad as it could be. It is essentially an oligopoly, along with Airbus, in the large passenger aircraft market (as well as in some military aerospace markets) and hence will survive through turbulence. But I suspect it will be a different organization after all this is said and done: it may actually may end up building more than 50% of a plane by itself!

Tags: ,

34 Response to The Disastrous Outsourcing of the 787

February 21, 2013 at 9:06 AM

nice blog, yours information is very effective. the information about cheap flights tickets IS TOO GOOD.

February 22, 2013 at 3:48 AM

NICE INFORMATION!!! Education is the process of bringing desirable change into the behavior of human beings. It can also be defined as the “Process of imparting or acquiring knowledge or habits through instruction or study”. Thanks for sharing a nice information.
Study Abroad in Canada
Study Masters in Canada

February 23, 2013 at 8:11 AM

This article gets it wrong.

Technology has moved ahead so much that it is no longer possible for any one company to have even a reasonable 'control' of the entire supply chain. For a surgeon in a operating theater, reliance on an anesthesiologist, a team of nurses, technicians is not a choice, it is inevitable for successful outcome.

In Boeing's case, the challenge of using Li-ion batteries was known before hand and deemed to be an acceptable risk. It was a known known (in the words of our beloved former Sec of Defense). The risk was taken and it failed. We are glad the no one was hurt or killed. We now go back to the drawing table and make changes to the battle plan.

A critical element of this change of plans would be how to have better coordination with our partners. Strengthen the 'outsourcing' of design, development and provisioning of systems and components to develop superior products or services.

There is folklore among Buddhists - the Jataka tales - in which a turtle falls from the sky when it talks while being carried by two swans on a stick that it holds tight with its mouth. The lesson - do not talk when you it is better to keep your mouth shut. How relevant to this turtle with flying on its mind...

February 23, 2013 at 1:22 PM

This sounds to me like it was more of a top-level design flaw in relying too heavily on battery power rather than a risk directly resulting from outsourcing.

February 26, 2013 at 10:13 PM

Anon 1,

Technology isn't the cause of the changes at Boeing. Most of what Boeing has done is business process re-engineering simply to improve their product (possibly in terms of cost, time to ship, etc). I don't think technology is at play here because Boeing is in an oligopoly and is the dominant player and hence dictates the markets. It's not as if another company is leapfrogging Boeing by utilizing better technology.

I don't know if I'm right but I do get the feeling that the "outsourcing trend" may have run its course. In business, there is always trends that are taken to the extreme and then fail. Six Sigma is a good example of that--companies who has no skills in that or where those quality processes don't apply started implementing them.

In the case of Boeing, it apparently assembles less than 50% of the plane, and likely designs a similar proportion of the components (although it may carry out most of the high-level design). The question for Boeing shareholders and senior management is what is Boeing if it doesn't even assemble half the plane. Is it simply a design firm (like, say, Dell is to the PC business)? If it simply becomes a design firm for such a complex product, it will likely be a smaller firm.

February 26, 2013 at 10:16 PM

Anon 2: "This sounds to me like it was more of a top-level design flaw in relying too heavily on battery power rather than a risk directly resulting from outsourcing."

Some critics claim that if Boeing was designing and manufacturing the batteries themselves (or some other alternate solution), they would have had better control. By outsourcing many of the key components, Boeing appears to have lost control of quality.

In any case, although I didn't go into it and I probably should have, the outsourcing problems with Boeing is not limited to the battery problem; they faced serious problems a few years ago and ended up with delays that cost billions.

I still feel that they outsourced too much of the company.

February 27, 2013 at 9:29 AM

I’m not certain the things I could possibly have tried in the absence of those aspects shared by you about this area. Entirely was a real difficult concern in my circumstances, but taking note of a professional manner you managed it took me to cry with fulfillment. I am happy for your support and then have high hopes you find out what a great job your are doing training people using your web page. Most likely you’ve never met any of us.

Cheap Airlines Tickets

March 22, 2013 at 4:59 PM

Its amazing what some companies will do to save a few pennies. Boeing is a great example. Outsourcing production to other countries to save money you know now that really sounds familiar does in it. Its sort of a lot like another example some years back a large percentage of dog and cat food companies were outsourcing and contracting out production of some of their dog and cat food products to a small almost unknown company menu foods. Turns out some of the ingredients that menu foods was using in their dog and cat food were being imported from a company based in china and some of the food was contaminated with a chemical used to make plastic.

April 5, 2013 at 3:47 AM

I heard that Philippines is one of the best in terms of outsourcing and there are lots of BPO companies were build in the Philippines and this is really big advantage for the Filipinos.

philippines outsourcing

August 2, 2013 at 6:41 AM

Outsourcing process is almost common in all fields . Many electronics and software concern also forward their task to IT outsourcing companies in UAE and other regions of the world.

February 18, 2017 at 11:43 PM

This is very nice post.I like this type of post.becousre it is a outsourcing releted post.

February 18, 2017 at 11:53 PM

It uses twenty per cent less fuel than its peers, and so is outsourcing to run, yet it also manages to have higher ceilings and larger windows.

January 28, 2018 at 5:05 AM

HTET Online Board of School Education Haryana (BSEH) will declare the result of HTET in January 2018.

April 15, 2018 at 4:13 AM

Как найти Поставщика?, В этом видео я расскажу о 11 способов найти поставщика для своего интернет-магазина. Это уже второе видео на эту темы на канале. Я узнал о новых способах и изложил в видео. Я лично не всеми способами пользовался. Поставщики. Где их найти для интернет магазина? Это вопрос раньше беспокоил и меня. Смотрите видео - вы узнаете как лучше Вам работать с поставщиками и где вы можете их найти. Больше статей о запуске интернет-магазина можно прочесть на моем блоге - Читаете описание к видео? Тогда вот ссылка на небольшую базу поставщиков - (Может быть, что часть уже не актуальна, буду рад, если этот список Вам поможет) В данном видео узнаете как и где найти поставщика для интернет-магазина. По своим тренингам я знаю, что люди часто боятся открыть свой магазин, потому что не верят, что могут найти поставщика для интернет-магазина. Смотрите это видео, что бы знать как найти поставщика для магазина.

April 17, 2018 at 2:49 AM

great news article, Sacramento based agency that helped hundreds of businesses realize their potential. The company keeps improving and mastering new techniques of climbing Google rankings fast.

April 17, 2018 at 3:01 AM

Lucid dreaming, Are you trying to lucid dream? Do you need help on how to lucid dream? Check out this website to learn more | Are you looking for ways to have vivid, colorful dreams? Check out this site to learn how and even have the chance to learn how to lucid dream | Lucid dreaming takes a lot of practice and can be difficult. Need some help? Check out this website to see how it can help you

April 21, 2018 at 1:37 AM

fertiliser firm Former LSE boss Xavier Rolet nominated to join the board of Russian fertiliser firm Phosagro

April 21, 2018 at 2:08 AM

barber motorsports park Hey guys how's it going? Today we're going to go for a lap around Barber Motorsports Park in a Dallara IR-18 with Josh Herman.

So as we come down the front straightaway it's a real fast track, it's a left hander with lots of elevation change and a deep braking point.

You go smashing right through that turn you wanna keep the speed up and then it's a long sweeper here going up this hill, man, it's a flat out corner right there you have to be careful coming down to the braking zone here...It's a late braking zone, it's probably the trickiest turn on the track you have to get a good exit out of here, but you can lose a lot of time.

Using up all the road as you see a little bit overboard there. This next part of the track is super fast you really have to push it to the limit right here as you can see locking up the brakes and jumping over the curbs and then really get a quick exit out of this turn using up all the track.

This is a pretty simple left hander you don't want to use a lot of curb there because if you do your car bounces around and you lose time.

This you want to do flat out right here and then down to 4th gear, over the hill, around this is where you cover really high speed umm it's really tricky you know your wheels can come off the ground.

Other than that, that's a lap at Barber Motorsports Park. I hope you guys enjoyed the video.

Want more info? Check us out at:

Computer : Alienware 15r3
Wheel Set : Logitech G29
Stand : Wheel Stand Pro Deluxe
Headphones : Logitech Artemis Wireless Headphones
Video Editing Software : Camtasia
Microphone : Blue Yeti

April 22, 2018 at 1:24 AM

Electrician Liverpool RAP Electrical are a electrical contractors based in the Northwest in Liverpool but carrying out electrical services across the whole of the UK. We special in fixed wire and emergency light testing.

April 22, 2018 at 1:54 AM

hemroid Harry review|about me do you suffer with hemorrhoids, then look no further, check out this new hemorrhoid treatment blog and find a solution|are those hemorrhoids still being a pain in your butt, then visit this website and to your problem find a 100% organic natural solution|if you are looking for a chemically free, organic remedy for those annoying hemorrhoids, then take a look at this website and discover a 100% natural herbal remedy

April 25, 2018 at 1:22 AM

review A site dedicated to reviewing guitar effects pedals.

April 25, 2018 at 2:04 AM

Remote Collaborations Successful Remote Project” [/url] There are several challenges when it comes to managing a project on which people work from various locations. Project management can become a bit difficult when teammates work remotely. However, as it was proven by various companies time and time again, completing projects using teams that work from home or remote locations is very possible

April 26, 2018 at 9:51 AM

truck accident lawyer truck accident lawyer

May 15, 2018 at 2:58 AM

<a href="”> dry shampoo </a> are you trying to get rid of greasy,dirty hair and do are you tired of wasting time to wash your hair, then check out this new dry shampoo review blog which shows you exactly how|having problems with oily hair in the morning, then go to this website to learn about an awesome dry shampoo|are your tired of being worried about your hair looking greasy when you leave the house, then check out this blog which shows you the best dry shampoo for greasy hair|do you no longer want to wash your hair every couple days? Check out this website to learn about the best dry shampoo to make your hair look fresh

May 16, 2018 at 11:30 AM

Bodybuilding This delicious organic coffee is incredibly high in antioxidants. In fact, it tested higher by as much as 10 times the amount in other coffee.
It is certified mold and pesticide free. Plus it tastes incredible! So if you're serious about what goes in your body, give it a try.

May 17, 2018 at 12:30 PM

find prostitutes in Chicago Are you unsure where to find prostitutes in Chicago? Then check out this new blog, which shows you how find prostitutes in Chicago. | Having problems on where to find prostitutes in Chicago? Then go to this blog for Chicago Prostitutes $75

May 18, 2018 at 1:27 AM

Best Sewing Machine for Beginners 2018 Ultimate guide to choosing the best sewing machine for beginners. Here you will find the best in Brother, Singer and Janome entry level sewing machines.

May 19, 2018 at 3:01 PM

flat stomach overnight Weight loss

May 21, 2018 at 1:00 AM

hunting Great advice for outdoor enthusiasts looking for new activities to enjoy!

May 24, 2018 at 1:56 PM

punching dummy for sale cheap Want to punch harder and faster? The only way to do that if to figure out schedule on practice. This is going to be extremely hard for some and easy for others. The best recommendation I can make would be for you to purchase a home punching bag or punching dummy. Find an affordable punching bag for sale you can use at any point in the day. This will give you more practice then any gym can. Push yourself to practice daily on your outdoor punching dummy. Check out the tips laid out here.

May 25, 2018 at 3:22 AM

Baroneess Susan Greenfield Read more about Baroness Susan Greenfield and her new book Mind the Change. Baroness Greenfield collates scientific research on how digital technology affects our brains. Find out more here.

May 25, 2018 at 3:43 AM

David Hill Guildford Welcome to the David Hill Guildford Crunchbase page. Connect with David Hill here to join his network and find out and find out about his latest achievements.

May 25, 2018 at 4:00 PM

Melamine Hardwood Lumber Alternative an environmental and economical alternative to traditional hardwoods without compromising on the durability and fine wood look you have come to expect with natural hardwoods.

May 27, 2018 at 2:36 PM

oxford Richard Lofthouse talks to Guy Hands about deal-making, dyslexia, and building a positive legacy.

Post a Comment